Best Overall
Garmin Swim 2
Key details
- Battery Life
- 7 days smartwatch, 13 hours GPS+OHR, 72 hours pool+OHR
- Swim Metrics
- Distance, pace, stroke count and type, SWOLF
- Open-water GPS
- Built-in GPS
- Water Resistance
- 50 meters
The Garmin Swim 2 is the only watch here built around swimming first. Its pool mode records distance, pace, stroke count, stroke type, and SWOLF, while open-water mode uses built-in GPS for distance, pace, stroke count, stroke rate, and stroke distance. That is the difference between a tracker that notices you were in the water and one that gives you a set worth reviewing.
We wore it for pool sets and came away liking the button controls more than we expected; wet fingers and touchscreens are a bad pair. The 1.04-inch display is small, but it is readable, and the battery rating separates the modes properly: 7 days in smartwatch mode, 13 hours with GPS and optical heart rate, and 72 hours in pool mode with optical heart rate. Underwater heart rate is a genuine bonus for interval work.
The Swim 2 is a specialist, and the button-first design is part of that bargain. We are happy to trade a bright touchscreen for the swim data, especially since the 72-hour pool battery means it is ready for a week of sessions. If you want one watch for laps and daily notifications, the vivoactive 5 is the easier fit; if the swim data comes first, start here.
Pros
- Full pool and open-water swim metrics
- Underwater heart rate for pool intervals
- 72 hours in pool mode with heart rate
- Button controls work with wet hands
Cons
- Lap counts can drift with pauses or mixed strokes
We recommend the Garmin Swim 2 for swimmers who want lap, stroke, and open-water data without a multisport watch.