Best Overall
HANDBODE Hex Dumbbell Pair, 17.5 lb
Key details
- Head Design
- Hex, rubber encased
- Set Contents
- Pair
- Handle Diameter
- 34 mm
- Weight Per Dumbbell
- 17.5 lb
The jump from 15 to 20 pounds is where a lot of home programs stall, and HANDBODE sells a 17.5-pound pair for exactly that gap. What got our attention is the handle: 28 mm on anything 12 pounds and lighter, 34 mm from 15 pounds up. A handle that stays skinny while the heads get bigger is how a heavy dumbbell starts to feel like it is rotating in your palm, and this is the only pair here that scales the grip with the load. That detail earns it the top spot.
You get two matched dumbbells in one box, cast iron under a virgin-rubber casing, with hex heads that sit still on the floor instead of rolling under the couch. The knurling is the part we keep coming back to — textured enough to hold a set of rows with sweaty hands, but not so sharp that it marks your palms during high-rep work.
The rubber does announce itself. There is a tire-like smell when the box opens and it hangs around for a few days, so give them a spot in the garage or on a porch before they come into the living room. That is the price of a casing that protects the floor and keeps the heads quiet when you set them down, and we will take it over bare iron that chips paint.
The line runs from 2.5 to 65 pounds, so the pair you buy now is a step rather than a commitment. Weigh both when they land, since cast heads are poured rather than machined, and if one is noticeably light compared with its twin, exchange it before the window closes.
Pros
- Half-size 17.5-pound pair fills the 15-to-20 gap
- Handle thickens to 34 mm above 15 pounds
- Textured knurling grips without marking palms
- Virgin rubber hex heads protect floors
Cons
- Rubber smell lingers for the first few days
We recommend these as the pair to build a home gym around: a handle that thickens with the weight, a half-size step that keeps progress gradual, and a rubber casing that survives a home floor.