Best Overall
ALOCANE Max Burn Gel
Key details
- Size
- 4 fl oz
- Also Contains
- Aloe vera, vitamin E
- Active Ingredients
- 4% lidocaine, benzalkonium chloride
Two ingredients put the Alocane tube ahead of everything else here: 4% lidocaine and benzalkonium chloride. The lidocaine does the numbing, and the antiseptic is there for the reason a household burn worries us more than a beach burn does — skin that's broken, in a kitchen, next to a cutting board. It's the combination we want in a first-aid drawer, and it's the tube we name when someone asks for one burn gel and doesn't want to think about it further.
The gel is thick and aloe-based with vitamin E, and it goes on clear. A thin layer covers a splash burn across the back of a hand, and it stays where it's put instead of running down a wrist. On sunburn, the lidocaine earns its keep on the parts that sting when a shirt touches them — shoulders, the tops of feet — while the aloe keeps skin from feeling tight afterward. Unlike a dedicated after-sun, it also lists minor cuts and scrapes, which is why it ends up in the first-aid box rather than the beach bag.
Four ounces is a drawer size, not a family size. If you're covering a back and legs every few hours through a beach weekend, one of the bigger bottles below goes further for less. Where this one wins is the burn that has already happened and hurts: a curling iron, a skillet, hot water from a kettle. That's the moment you want lidocaine rather than another layer of aloe.
What settles it for us is the arithmetic of a small kit. One compact tube that numbs, protects against germs, and moisturizes replaces three things you otherwise carry, and it costs about what the single-purpose gels here do.
Pros
- 4% lidocaine for real numbing
- Antiseptic for broken kitchen skin
- Covers both burns and sunburn
- Compact tube suits a first-aid drawer
Cons
- Can sting briefly on open skin
- Thick gel feels gooey until it dries
The one we reach for first, for anyone who wants a single gel that numbs a skillet splash, guards it against germs, and calms a sunburn.