Best Overall
Easy Spirit Romy
Key details
- Widths
- Wide and extra-wide
- Closure
- Lace-up
- Cushioning
- Soft, padded
Width is where a walking shoe either works for an older foot or doesn't, and it's the first thing we checked on the Romy. It comes in wide and extra-wide, and the toe box stays roomy rather than tapering to a point. A foot that has spread, or that swells by late afternoon, still fits in the shoe at four o'clock. That combination — a real width range plus a soft, padded footbed — is why it's our top pick for women.
Cushioning is soft without going mushy. We walked in these on pavement and on hard indoor floors, and the sole takes a heel strike and rolls forward without the tippy, boat-like feel of a very thick rocker. The arch is contoured rather than flat, and the effect shows up in the stride: this is a shoe that turns a short, careful shuffle into a longer, more confident step. For a daily loop around the neighborhood or a morning of errands, that's the whole job.
It's also plain in the best sense. The white-and-navy colorway reads as an ordinary sneaker rather than a medical device, which matters more than it should when you're buying something you'll wear every day. Ours came out of the box ready to walk in, with no break-in to speak of, and at midrange money it's the best balance of support and width choice in this set.
Pros
- Wide and extra-wide sizes that stay roomy
- Soft cushioning with a contoured arch
- Steadier, longer stride on pavement
- Comfortable from the first wear
Cons
- Lace-up, so not hands-free
- Women's sizing only
Our top pick for women: the Romy comes in wide and extra-wide, cushions a full day on your feet, and produced the steadiest stride of anything we walked in.