Best Overall
Skechers Go Walk Max Effort
Key details
- Style
- Athletic walking sneaker
- Upper
- Breathable mesh
- Outsole
- Curved rocker shape
Soft is the whole idea here, and this is the softest shoe in the roundup. The Go Walk Max Effort is what we point to when someone wants to walk more and think about their feet less: the cushioning is deep enough to take the sting out of a concrete sidewalk, the shoe weighs next to nothing, and it costs less than every other pair on this page. For a first walking shoe, or for a job that keeps you upright all day, that combination is hard to argue with.
Airflow is the other thing it gets right. The mesh upper moves heat out instead of trapping it, which matters more than it sounds for something worn from May through September. There is almost nothing to break in, either — it feels soft from the first walk, which is not something we can say for the leather pair further down. The look is plain enough for jeans and does not announce itself as gym gear.
What the softness costs is stability. The sole is curved and cushy, and across a rutted field or a sloped lawn it rolls toward the outer edge rather than planting, so we keep this pair to sidewalks, park paths, and the treadmill. Arch support is light, too; if you have high arches, drop in your own insert and let the cushioning do the rest of the work. On flat, paved ground — which is most of what walking is — neither of those shows up.
Pros
- Deep cushioning that softens concrete
- Barely-there weight for long days
- Breathable mesh upper for warm weather
Cons
- Outsole and heel cushioning wear out before the upper does
We recommend the Go Walk Max Effort to anyone who wants the softest ride for the least money — it is the most comfortable shoe here, as long as your walking stays on paved ground.