Best Overall
Easy Spirit Romy Walking Sneaker
Key details
- Widths
- Medium, wide, and extra wide
- Closure
- Lace-up
- Toe Box
- Roomy
Every cushioned shoe in this group asks a heavier walker to trade a little steadiness for softness. The Romy comes closest to refusing the trade. The footbed is cushioned enough for a full day on concrete, but the sole is broad and planted rather than tall and squishy, so you get support under the arch instead of a wobble between steps. We spent a long afternoon on hard floors in these and never felt the shoe bottom out.
Fit is why it ends up first. Romy runs from medium through extra wide, the toe box is genuinely roomy, and the lacing lets you snug the midfoot without pressing across the top of the foot. Most of us took our usual length and went down a width; if you are between sizes, that is the direction to move. It is rare in this group for the wide version to feel like a properly different shoe rather than a longer piece of fabric.
The arch is shaped and moderately firm rather than a soft pad — the kind of support that gives a flat foot something to push against. If you already wear orthotics, bring them when you try a pair on; the roomy fit leaves space, but a thick insole will crowd the toe box in a shoe this cushioned.
It won't win a style contest — it is a sensible-looking walking shoe and reads that way — but that is a fair trade for something this predictable underfoot. Our advice: buy two pairs if the budget allows and alternate them, because rotating shoes is the cheapest way to make any walking shoe last longer.
Pros
- Cushioned for full days on hard floors
- Roomy toe box in wide and extra-wide
- Firm, shaped arch support
Cons
- Wide widths run wider than expected
If you want one pair that stays comfortable and steady through long days on hard floors, this is the walking shoe we recommend — and its wide and extra-wide sizes mean more feet can actually wear it.