Best Overall
Metamucil Psyllium Fiber Powder
Key details
- Form
- Powder
- Flavor
- Sugar-free orange
- Servings
- 180 teaspoons
- Fiber Type
- Psyllium husk
A teaspoon of this stirred into a full glass of water is the closest thing to a default in this category, and it's the one we keep coming back to. Psyllium bulks and gels rather than dissolving away, which is the action you want when stools are hard and infrequent. The orange flavor is genuinely drinkable, and because you measure it yourself, you can start with half a spoonful and build up over a week instead of committing to a full dose on day one.
That dial matters more than it sounds. Capsules and gummies arrive in fixed units; a tub lets you find the smallest dose that works, which is how you avoid the cramping that comes from going from no fiber to a lot of it overnight. At 180 teaspoons, this tub also lasts long enough that the cost per glass lands well under the premeasured sticks and the premium gummies.
The texture is the thing to make peace with. Psyllium starts setting the moment it hits liquid, so stir briskly, drink it straight down, and chase it with another half glass. Leave it on the counter for two minutes and you're spooning pudding. We made it a fixed part of the morning — same glass, same time — and found it far more useful as a daily habit than as an emergency measure after a bad week.
Pros
- Dose you can dial from half a spoon up
- Gel-forming psyllium, the bulking fiber
- 180 teaspoons per tub, low cost per glass
- Pleasant sugar-free orange flavor
Cons
- Contains aspartame and maltodextrin
Our pick for most people: a measured spoonful of gel-forming psyllium in a glass of water, in a tub that lasts months and a flavor that's easy to finish.