Best Overall
Barebells Cookies & Cream
Key details
- Added Sugars
- None
- Bars Per Box
- 12
- Total Sugars
- 0.04 oz
- Protein Per Bar
- 0.71 oz
Twenty grams of protein and one gram of sugar rarely reads like a treat, but this bar gets closer than anything else in the group. It is soft through the middle with little crispy bits running through the coating, so it eats like a chocolate bar rather than a slab of whey, and the cookies and cream flavor is genuinely sweet instead of merely sweetish.
We kept coming back to it for exactly that reason. Flavor is what makes a bar worth buying a second box of, and this is the best-tasting bar here — texture included, which is where most high-protein bars lose people. The macros are not a consolation prize either: 20 grams of protein for a gram of total sugar, with no added sugar in the recipe.
The one honest caveat is what it costs. This sits in the top price tier of the set, and a bar a day adds up faster than the box suggests. It is also not a meal — it is a snack that happens to hit a protein number, and it is soft enough to eat without a drink, which matters more than it sounds when you are eating at a desk or on a trail.
Pros
- Best flavor and texture in this set
- 20g protein with 1g total sugar
- No added sugar in the recipe
Cons
- Top price tier of this group
The best-tasting bar in this group and the one we point people to first: 20 grams of protein and a single gram of sugar, in a bar that eats like a chocolate treat.