Best Overall
Sawyer 20% Picaridin Lotion
Key details
- Form
- Lotion
- Size
- 4 fl oz (2-pack)
- Tick Protection
- Up to 12 hours
- Active Ingredient
- 20% picaridin
Twelve hours is the figure that settled this one for us. Most tick repellents ask you to stop what you're doing and reapply halfway through the afternoon; this 20% picaridin lotion is labeled for up to 12 hours against both mosquitoes and ticks, which covers a full hike or a Saturday of yard work in a single application.
The format is why we keep coming back to it. Pumped lotion goes exactly where you put it — around the ankle bones, along the sock line, at the waistband, behind the knee — which is where ticks actually make contact. You can see the film while you're rubbing it in, so the gap you missed is obvious. It dries down quickly and doesn't leave the slick, sticky residue that makes people skip repellent altogether.
Picaridin is also kinder to gear than DEET. It won't damage plastics or synthetic coatings, so a watch strap, sunglass frames, or a pack that catches overspray comes out fine. The formula is fragrance-free, and on a warm day that is the difference between wearing repellent and enduring it.
No repellent holds its full clock through heavy sweat or a swim, and this one is no exception — the label's 12 hours assumes a dry, ordinary day outside. That is still most of the tick days we plan for: a morning on the trail, an afternoon of raking, the walk where the grass reaches your calves.
Pros
- Up to 12 hours against ticks and mosquitoes
- Fragrance-free and non-greasy on skin
- Safe on plastics, watches, and pack straps
- Lotion shows you where you've covered
Cons
- Slower to apply to a group than a spray
- Two bottles go quickly for a family
Our default for a day outdoors: 20% picaridin gives up to 12 hours against ticks, goes on like hand lotion, and leaves no scent behind.