Best Overall
Murphy's Naturals Repellent Spray
Key details
- Form
- Pump spray
- Size
- 2 fl oz, pack of 3
- Protection Time
- Up to 6 hrs mosquitoes, 4 hrs ticks
- Active Ingredient
- 30% oil of lemon eucalyptus
Thirty percent oil of lemon eucalyptus, up to six hours against mosquitoes and four against ticks — that pairing is what settled this one for us. It's a plant-derived active with an EPA registration behind it, and it's the only pick here that also puts a number on tick protection. When a spray can tell you how long it works instead of how good it smells, that's the bottle we hand someone heading out for a long afternoon.
In the hand it behaves like a light lotion in spray form: thin going on, quick to dry, and without the shine that makes people skip repellent entirely. One bottle covers a pair of legs in a couple of passes. For faces, spray into your palms first — the label asks for that, and it's easier than chasing a moving child with a nozzle.
The spray format is also why it travels well. A three-bottle pack means one by the back door, one in the car, one in a hiking pack, and none of them precious enough to ration. Because ticks are on the label too, this is the one we take into tall grass rather than the one we take to a barbecue.
If you'd rather rub than spray, the lotion below is the swap, and a balm is easier on a child's hairline. For everything else — the long walk, the yard work, the evening when the mosquitoes arrive in numbers — this is the bottle we reach for first.
Pros
- States six hours against mosquitoes
- Only pick with a tick claim
- Dries fast without a greasy film
- Three bottles to scatter between bags
Cons
- Can sting on sensitive skin
- Lemon scent lingers after spraying
We recommend this to almost anyone who wants a natural repellent: a registered lemon eucalyptus formula that claims six hours, not just a pleasant scent.