Best Overall
Caltrate 600 + D3
Key details
- Tablet Count
- 200
- Calcium Per Tablet
- 600 mg
- Vitamin D3 Per Tablet
- 20 mcg (800 IU)
Eight hundred IU is the number that settled it. One Caltrate tablet carries 600 mg of calcium and 20 mcg (800 IU) of vitamin D3 — more D3 per tablet than any of the Citracal picks on this list — so two tablets a day covers the calcium and a serious share of the vitamin D without a second bottle on the counter.
The 600 mg dose is the other half of the case. Calcium is absorbed in limited amounts at a time, so a tablet this size splits cleanly: one with breakfast, one with dinner, and you're at 1,200 mg and 1,600 IU of D3. We were braced for a horse pill and found the coating does real work — it's a large tablet, but it goes down more easily than its size suggests, and a pill cutter settles the rest.
That combination is why this is the bottle we point most people toward. There's nothing to fuss over: take it with food, keep the bottle where you'll see it, and the routine is two swallows a day. It also sits mid-priced for the category rather than at either extreme, which is about right for something you'll rebuy every few months.
Two buyers should look elsewhere. If you take a stomach-acid reducer or want calcium you can take without a meal, citrate is the better fit and Citracal Petites is where to start. If a single daily dose is the only routine you'll keep, Citracal Slow Release does that job better than this bottle can.
Pros
- 800 IU of D3 per tablet, the most here
- 600 mg calcium splits into two daily doses
- Coated tablet swallows better than its size suggests
Cons
- Bottles can arrive with a short expiry date
We make this our top pick because 600 mg of calcium is easy to split across the day and each tablet brings more D3 than any Citracal here.