Best Overall
Ancient Nutrition Bone Broth Protein, Vanilla
Key details
- Flavor
- Vanilla
- Collagen Types
- I, II & III
- Protein Source
- Grass-fed beef bone broth
- Protein Per Serving
- 0.71 oz
Twenty grams of protein per scoop, no whey, no soy, no pea or rice protein: that is the combination most people are shopping for, and it is why this vanilla tub is the one we recommend first. It is made from grass-fed beef bone broth rather than a collagen isolate, and it carries collagen types I, II and III plus glucosamine, chondroitin and hyaluronic acid, which is the fullest joint-and-gut matrix of anything in this set.
Mixing is the price of that formulation. Stirred by hand into cold milk or water it clumps and leaves a tacky film on the glass, and stirring harder only makes it worse. In a blender it turns creamy and frothy, and the vanilla is sweet enough that plain water tastes like a melted milkshake. Our routine is a scoop with ice and unsweetened almond milk and no added sweetener, because the flavor is already there. If you want to stir and go, this is not the tub.
It sits easily, too. No bloating or heaviness after a morning shake, which is the whole reason people move to bone broth protein once whey stops agreeing with them. If you are sensitive, start with half a scoop for the first week and work up.
The jar is just over a pound, so a daily habit empties it faster than the two-pound tubs here. If the protein number is all you care about and the scoop is going into broth rather than a smoothie, the Zammex gets you the same 20 grams with cleaner mixing and a beefier flavor.
Pros
- 20 g of grass-fed bone broth protein
- Collagen I, II and III plus glucosamine and chondroitin
- Blends creamy and frothy in a blender
Cons
- Vanilla is noticeably sweet
For most people this is the one to buy: 20 grams of protein a scoop, the broadest collagen and joint-support mix here, and a smoothie texture that rewards a blender.