Best Overall
Nioxin System 2
Key details
- Size
- 10.1 oz
- Hair Type
- Natural, uncolored
- Thinning Stage
- Progressed thinning
- Key Ingredients
- Botanical antioxidants, UV protectors
The number on the bottle matters more than the word 'thickening.' Nioxin's System 2 is the version for natural, uncolored hair with progressed thinning, and that specificity is the first thing we check. The formula is built around scalp care: it lifts oil and buildup, then follows with botanical antioxidants and UV protectors. That is a more sensible approach for thinning hair than a heavy volumizer that makes strands look fuller for a day but leaves the scalp coated.
We recommend it as the default for anyone with visible thinning and uncolored hair. The minty tingle is refreshing, and the rinse leaves hair feeling clean rather than weighed down. More important, the formula is aimed at reducing breakage and improving the look of density, not just propping up the roots with styling polymers. The lather is easy to work through the scalp, and a little goes a reasonably long way.
What we don't love is the way it can leave already-dry ends feeling tighter, so a conditioner on the mid-lengths and ends is not optional in our book. And if you color your hair, this is the wrong Nioxin number; System 4 is the one built for color-treated, dry, damaged hair. The number is the most useful thing on the label: get it right and the rest of the routine gets simpler.
Pros
- Targets scalp buildup and breakage, not just volume
- Minty tingle feels refreshing
- Specific match for natural hair with progressed thinning
Cons
- Mint may irritate a sensitive scalp
- Costs more than basic thickening shampoos
Our best overall for natural, uncolored hair with noticeable thinning: it treats the scalp and breakage instead of just temporarily plumping strands.