Best Overall
Little Seed Farm Deodorant Cream
Key details
- Size
- 2.4 oz
- Scent
- Grapefruit Lemon
- Format
- Cream in glass jar
- Baking Soda
- Free
Our top pick doesn't come in a stick. Little Seed Farm's deodorant is a cream in a small glass jar, and the first thing we noticed was the texture: silky, closer to a thick lotion than the grainy pastes we've dug out of other jars. A little wooden scoop comes with it, though most of us just used a fingertip.
What earns it the top spot is the balance. It's the most complete formula here — odor control that holds through a workday and, just as importantly, underarms that stay calm. It's aluminum free and baking soda free, made with organic ingredients, and the grapefruit-lemon blend reads bright and clean rather than perfumey. For anyone who gave up on natural deodorant after a rash, this is the one to try next.
Application becomes second nature fast: a fingertip's worth on clean, dry skin right after a shower, and it sinks in without a wait. The scent fades close to the body by mid-morning, which we preferred to the sweeter sticks here, and it holds up through a workout better than most of the picks in this guide.
The cost is the honest caveat: it runs higher than the Native and Arm & Hammer sticks, and a 2.4-ounce jar doesn't stretch as far as a 4.25-ounce salt stick, so you'll be reordering sooner. The glass jar does get a second life holding hairpins in our bathroom, which softens it.
Pros
- Holds odor through a full workday
- Baking-soda-free formula that suits reactive skin
- Silky cream that sinks in without waiting
Cons
- Jar and fingertip application, not a bag stick
Buy this if you want one formula that holds all day and won't set your underarms on fire — the jar is the only thing to get used to.