Best Overall
NONYX Fungal Nail Clarifying Gel
Key details
- Size
- 4 fl oz (6-month supply)
- Application
- 3 times a month
- Under Polish
- Yes
- Active Ingredient
- Ethanoic acid
Three applications a month is the whole schedule. There's no morning ritual and no reapplying after every shower — a coat three times a month, ideally on the same dates so it becomes a calendar entry rather than a habit. The bottle is 4 ounces, which the brand reckons at a six-month supply, so one purchase covers most of the stretch it takes a toenail to grow out and be trimmed away.
We put it first because it's the most thoroughly backed formula here. The maker points to a double-blind, placebo-controlled study in which 90% of nails improved, and the product has been sold since 2004 with more than 8 million bottles bought in the U.S. alone. The active is ethanoic acid, which softens and clarifies the damaged plate instead of stripping it. It's also the only pick here that says it can be worn under nail polish, which means you can keep your hands and feet looking the way you like while the nail grows out.
Spend your attention at the base of the nail rather than the tip. That's the only place a topical can show you anything, because the discolored section has to grow forward and be cut off. Four ounces is also a long runway — with a pen or a small bottle you'll be reordering in the middle of the grow-out, which is exactly when people quit.
Pros
- Three applications a month, no daily ritual
- Four-ounce bottle covers about six months
- Can be worn under nail polish
- Backed by a placebo-controlled nail study
Cons
- Sharp vinegar scent while it dries
A three-times-a-month routine and a six-month bottle make this the one we tell most people to start with.